Javeria Shahid A Quick Guide
In this article, we will look at the age-old psychological conflict between determinism and free will. We will investigate determinism in terms of internal and external elements, including social, physical, psychological, and biological impacts, using real-life scenarios. We will also explore the relationship between determinism and free will and important psychological perspectives including behaviorism, psychoanalysis, and the humanistic viewpoint.
Introduction
The perpetual tug of war between determinism and free will has plagued psychology, questioning our understanding of human behavior. The determinist viewpoint limits human autonomy by assuming that both internal and external factors—such as biology, environment, psychology, and society—determine our behaviors. On the other hand, free will claims that humans are capable of making their own decisions.
What is Determinism?
The idea of determinism holds that factors outside of our control affect the decisions and behaviors we make. Determinism includes both external and internal influences, each of which has a unique effect on our actions. The four domains of these forces are social, physical, psychological, and biological. Let’s look into each dimension:
Internal Determinism
Biological Determinism: There is a strong hereditary component that shapes human behavior. For example, an individual’s susceptibility to addiction may be heightened by a genetic predisposition.
Psychological Determinism: This concept refers to the internal mechanisms of human consciousness. Psychoanalysis’s core concepts of unconscious impulses, emotions, and past experiences can influence our decision-making. Certain anxieties or behaviors that emerge later in life can be a result of traumatic childhood experiences. An example of the impact of internal psychological factors is the ability to link deeply rooted fears, such as arachnophobia (the fear of spiders), to certain past experiences or traumas.
External Determinism
Social Determinism: According to this concept, the people and things in our immediate surroundings influence the way we behave. Growing up in a society that prioritizes cooperation over competition, for instance, may encourage people to act more cooperatively in social situations.
Physical Determinism: The concept focuses on how our physical environment affects the things we do. There can be a significant impact from environmental factors like geography or climate. A person living in a sunny climate could have a different way of life than someone who lives in a colder area.
Understanding Free Will
The idea of free will holds that humans are capable of making decisions without interference from external or internal forces. There are two main ways that it appears:
Libertarian Free Will
According to this viewpoint, people are completely free to make their judgments without interference from outside forces. It assumes a certain degree of autonomy over one’s actions. Example: A person’s choice to follow an unconventional job path despite social norms demonstrates their libertarian free will beliefs. They demonstrate their independence by prioritizing their ideals and goals over those of others.
Compatibilism
Compatibilism, or soft determinism, is a philosophical and psychological perspective that aims to make a connection between the concepts of free will and determinism. According to this argument, free will is still possible even in the presence of internal and external influences on our decisions. Stated differently, humans possess the ability to make significant judgments despite the influence of multiple factors such as biology, environment, and upbringing on our behavior. According to compatibilists, determinism and free will are not contradictory; rather, they can coexist. This viewpoint preserves individual agency and choice while allowing for an extensive description of human behavior by recognizing the importance of both internal and external forces.
Psychological Approaches and Compatibilism
The conflict between compatibilism, sometimes known as soft determinism, and free will is seen in many psychological paradigms:
Behaviorism
B.F. Skinner promoted behaviorism, which tends determinism. It highlights how reinforcement and outside stimuli mold behavior. It does not, however, completely discount free will. In the context of behavior therapy, compatibilism enables us to see how people actively use their free will to overcome phobias, proving that conscious effort and free will can coexist with external influences.
Psychoanalysis
Sigmund Freud developed psychoanalysis, which explores the deterministic impact of the unconscious mind on behavior. Unresolved childhood conflicts, according to Freud, might influence an adult’s behavior. A person’s fear of commitment, for instance, could be attributed by Freud to unresolved issues from their early years. It emphasizes deterministic components like as unconscious desires, but it also recognizes the function of free will in bringing these unconscious elements to consciousness. Through active exploration and resolution of underlying impulses, people actively exercise their free will in therapy.
Humanistic Perspective
This viewpoint emphasizes human agency and self-actualization, and it is best represented by Abraham Maslow and Carl Rogers. Given that it emphasizes people’s ability to make decisions that support their personal development and fulfillment, it strongly relates to the idea of free will. It opposes determinism by promoting the idea that people are capable of self-actualization and conscious decision-making.
All in all, compatibilism, under these psychological frameworks, offers a link between determinism and free will. By emphasizing the intricate relationship between internal and external factors, human agency, and conscious decision-making, psychology can provide a more thorough explanation of human behavior.
Key Takeaway
The argument over free will vs determinism is not just an abstract philosophical issue; it is at the heart of psychology. Gaining knowledge of how both external and internal influences mold our actions, as well as the connections between these ideas and psychological philosophies such as behaviorism, psychoanalysis, and the humanistic viewpoint, enhances our understanding of human nature. We keep debating the interaction between determinism and free will to grasp the complexity of human behavior and discover the fundamental qualities that make each of us special.
The Historical origins of Applied Behavior Analysis ABA Therapy